FLORIDA’S NARROW ESCAPE FROM GEORGIA

The Military Exploits of An Exceptional Revolutionary Hero, Samuel Elbert

by R. E. Whitehead

(based on an account by Stella Muse Whitehead)

(NOTE: Much of this article is now available at Wikipedia, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Elbert.)

Over fifteen million people live in Florida and millions more visit the Sunshine State annually, yet few, if any realize that, but for the capricious winds, they might well be living or visiting in southern Georgia. A little known incident many years ago came very close to changing the boundaries of Georgia to include all, or at least the northern part of Florida. This incident occurred during the American revolution and involved some of Georgia’s early heroes including one Lt. Colonel Samuel Elbert. Colonel Elbert, along with Colonel John Baker, commanded an expedition to annex Florida and stop once and for all the foraging expeditions into Georgia by the British and Indians of Florida. 

Samuel Elbert’s parents died in South Carolina when Elbert was only a boy. Samuel, an orphan at the age of fourteen, set out to make his way in life. He traveled back to his birth place, Savannah, Georgia where he went to work as an Indian trader. Being industrious and very honest as well as kind and gentle, Samuel soon made many friends among both the settlers and the Indians. Samuel’s only goal seemed to be to work hard and do what was right. 

At an early age, Samuel was employed by a prosperous planter named John Rae, one of the most important figures at that time, in both the commercial field and in governmental affairs, in the entire State of Georgia. Mr. Rae had built a beautiful home on his land near Savannah known as Rae’s Hall. It was through John Rae's influence that Elbert was commissioned to go into Indian country as a trader, and he had great success in his dealings with the Indians, mostly because of his kind regard for those members of the human race termed our “darker-skin brothers.” John Rae had a talented daughter, Elizabeth Rae, and soon she and Elbert became engaged. In 1769, they were married at Rae’s Hall, a marriage that, according to historian Charles C. Jones, “confirmed Elbert’s social position and influence.” 

Although never seeking glory, it seemed to seek Elbert out and it wasn’t long before he found himself a leader in Georgia’s movement for independence. He was intensely loyal and it was difficult for him to renounce his loyalty to the Crown, but events soon made it inevitable. He was ambitious, but not to the point of sacrificing his principles. Later in his career, when the General Assembly of Georgia requested that he take command of all the Continental troops of the State to replace General McIntosh, Elbert declined. He wrote that, “as long as General McIntosh desires that position, I am unwilling to accept it.” Elbert placed his duty as a soldier above his personal ambition, saying that he was bound to obey the General. It is very much to his credit that he never entered into petty quarrels, reserving his battles for the British. Joseph Clay, one of Georgia’s outstanding political leaders and later delegate to the Continental Congress, said of Samuel Elbert:

“ - he is active, vigilant and brave and much respected by the inhabitants.” 

Although not quite as well known as some of Georgia’s other leaders, Elbert was nevertheless very active in the quest to obtain freedom from Britain. Prior to the outset of Colonial disputes, Elbert, as did many other Georgians, displayed an intense loyalty toward England. He became a captain in the Colonial Militia and signed a pledge of allegiance to the King of England as a pre-requisite to being commissioned a Captain in the Colonial Army in 1774. His innate sense of justice, however, broke strong barriers when the British sent battleships into Savannah Harbor, and burned rice plantations along the Savannah river. This act of violent tyranny ended once and for all any loyalty he might have had for the crown.  
 
He became active in the Provisional Congress of Georgia and its outgrowth, the Georgia Council of Safety which laid the basis for an independent American government. At the suggestion of a committee of the Council of Safety, the companies of the Georgia Militia decided to elect their own officers. As a result, in 1775, all officers loyal to the King were replaced with staunch supporters of the oppositionist cause. On February 4, 1776, Elbert was made a Lieutenant Colonel of the Continental troops. A handsome and gallant military officer, “Samuel Elbert contributed as much as any other man to the early movement for Georgia’s independence”, according to researcher C. E. Purcell. 

It was in 1777 when Georgia’s president, Button Gwinnett, decided to conduct an invasion of Florida to liberate that territory from the British. His plan was to send Lt. Colonel Samuel Elbert with 400 continental troops in three galleys and support craft by sea and another element of 109 mounted militia led by Colonel John Baker by land. The two elements were to rendezvous at Saw Pit Bluff, near the mouth of the Nassau River, a site that is presently within the city limits of Jacksonville, Florida.

Unfortunately at the very time this expedition was initiated, an ongoing feud between President Button Gwinnett and the commander of Georgia’s Continental troops, General Lachlan McIntosh, brought about the demise of Mr. Gwinnett. A duel between these two individuals caused both to suffer wounds and Button Gwinnett died of blood poisoning three days later on May 19, 1977. General McIntosh apparently resented not having been put in charge of the Florida expedition and it is entirely possible that with his more skillful planning, the campaign just might have succeeded.

Nevertheless, probably the single most important reason Florida never became a part of Georgia can be found in the vagaries of the wind.* May 13, 1777 was to be the date for Elbert and Baker to combine their forces and drive back the British. As it happened, about this time, the coastal winds chose to blow strongly from a Southerly direction. This, together with opposing currents, prevented Elbert’s sea expedition from reaching its destination on the date selected. President and Commander in Chief Gwinnett, who planned the sojourn, had failed to allow sufficient time for adverse conditions to prevail. 

Colonel Baker’s mounted militia arrived at Saw Pitt Bluff as planned but quickly moved to a new location when it became apparent that the British already knew of their intentions. During this move, Colonel Baker’s men were surprised by an overwhelming force of some 400 British troops and a brief battle ensued in the vicinity of Thomas Creek just South of where it empties into the Nassau River. Today, this site is just West of I-95 where it crosses the Nassau River near Jacksonville. 

Greatly outnumbered and facing withering fire, most of Baker’s men deserted. Colonel Baker together with his few remaining forces was obliged to retreat, disengaging the enemy and returning to Georgia on May 17. It was about three days later, after struggling with adverse winds, that Colonel Elbert arrived and disembarked on the North end of Amelia Island. His forces were joined by a few stragglers from Baker’s detachment, but after reconnoitering, Elbert found the British well entrenched with troops and artillery as well as an armed schooner and sloop guarding the passage between Amelia Island and the mainland.

While Elbert’s little band was busy trying to cut through the Amelia Narrows, the British commander, Patrick Tonyn, was making plans to attack them with vastly superior forces. To ensure total victory, the British war ships Rebecca and Hawke were ordered out to block any attempt of Elbert’s little flotilla to escape. 

But Mother Nature plays no favorites. After thwarting Elbert’s invasion of Florida with uncooperative winds, the weather quickly changed. A violent storm came up, and the British war ships were forced out to sea. Before they could return, they encountered a rebel Brigantine of sixteen guns. The ensuing battle damaged the Rebecca so badly, that it could no longer carry on, leaving Elbert’s exit from Amelia Island unopposed. 

Failing to surprise the British and not having the support of Baker’s detachment, Elbert and his men returned to Georgia without much having been accomplished. Shortly thereafter, Elbert concluded in a letter to General McIntosh, “ I think --- that little can be done, unless by a formidable invasion, which I judge to be rather too much for Georgia to undertake till her forces are put on a more respectable footing, and therefore recommend confining our operations entirely to the defensive till a more favorable opportunity. We have too many secret enemies amongst us who keep up a regular correspondence with our Florida neighbors, and until they are put to a stop it will impossible for us to enter Florida without their having timely notice of our approach.” 

A later attempt to invade Florida with a much larger army hardly got off the ground. This attack, in which Elbert played a somewhat lesser role, was initiated by Governor John Houston and General Robert Howe in 1778. It was doomed to failure from the start by lack of a unified command. One of the few, and most amazing, successes of this second invasion attempt came when Colonel Elbert put 300 of his troops aboard three Rebel galleys and caused the surrender of two British warships, his Majesty’s schooner Hinchinbrook and the recently repaired sloop-of-war Rebecca, that had been harassing the Georgia Rebels for almost two years. Also captured was a prize brigantine. At the sight of the heavily manned Rebel galleys approaching, the British struck their colors and abandoned ship.

Elbert was ecstatic. The remarkable success of this enterprise encouraged him to launch his Galleys against a third British vessel anchored at the North end of Jekyll Island. The Captain of this British ship, the Galatea, apparently wanted no part in engaging the rebel gun-boats and managed to evade the attack and put to sea. General Howe commended Elbert and his troops in glorious terms for their victory over the British ships and, partly because of this venture, decided to continue with his attack on Florida

It is interesting that the Galleys used by Colonel Elbert comprised almost the entire Georgia Navy at that time. These vessels were named the Lee, the Washington and the Bulloch. A fourth Galley, named the Congress, completed all the ships authorized by the Continental Congress for the State. The Congress, however, was not used by Elbert at this time. The Galleys were about 70 feet in length and were powered by two lateen sails as well as oars and had either a large cannon or two carriage guns mounted in the bow. Although not suited for ocean going, their maneuverability made them formidable in the shallow coastal waters of Georgia.

Meanwhile, Samuel Elbert, having been made acting brigadier-general, continued with his Continental troops toward Florida. Just after they crossed the Satilla River, on June 24th, an unusual event may have provided an ominous warning. On that day, the first solar eclipse recorded in the British colonies occurred. It was called "the dark day", the day of the great eclipse of the sun by the troops and may well have been responsible for some of the desertions that occurred about then. 

Elbert, now joined by General Howe, continued on and captured Fort Tonyn which had been deserted by the British. It was here that problems began to arise. Houston and Howe were unable to agree on who would lead the continentals in the invasion and the rebel naval commander, Commodore Oliver Bowen, refused to be subordinate to the Army elements. This confusion, plus lack of surprise and widespread illness among the troops caused the invaders to be halted in a battle at a place called Alligator Bridge. In a typically political fashion, General Howe announced that “our principal objective has been accomplished” and returned his troops to Georgia. Although the skirmishes between the Patriots and the Loyalists continued, the 1778 expedition was the last of Georgia’s attempts to throw the British out of Florida

Elbert continued to be active in Georgia’s quest for freedom and after Georgia became a State, he was elected Governor to succeed John Houston. In November, 1788, after a lingering sickness, Samuel Elbert died at the age of 48. He was buried on an Indian King's mound, overlooking the Savannah River. At the beginning of the twentieth century, the Sons of The American Revolution appointed a committee to locate Samuel Elbert's grave. After many efforts the grave-site was found. On March 24, 1924, Samuel Elbert and his wife Elizabeth Rae Elbert were re-interred in the Colonial Park Cemetery in Savannah. Many honors were paid this great leader in this military funeral. Units from the Army, Navy and National Guard united in honoring the memory of one of Georgia’s greatest heroes.


NOTES

*  In any case, whatever the reason, which may have included low water with the wind, Elbert was unable to make it up the river.

For more information on the ships and battle, see GA Gen Web Page, "Georgia Revolutionary War" (http:/www.rootsweb.com/~gataylor/elbert.htm).






[Home]